Dram Shop Actions: When a Bar Goes too Far

The Lento Law Group, P.C. • March 18, 2021

Now that Saint Patrick’s Day is just around the corner, personal injury attorneys brace themselves for an influx of motor vehicle accident cases involving intoxicated drivers. While most people who are injured in an accident with a drunk driver are aware of their ability to sue the driver for damages, many people do not realize that they may also be entitled to pursue an action against the individual or entity which provided the driver with the alcoholic beverages.


Any server of alcoholic beverages in the State of New Jersey, be they a bar, a restaurant, or even your friend hosting a party, should be well acquainted with New Jersey’s “dram shop” laws.


What is Dram Shop Liability?


In order to understand New Jersey’s dram shop laws, first it would be helpful to understand what a dram shop is. Put simply, “dram shop” is simply an antiquated term for a bar, tavern, or similar commercial establishment where alcoholic beverages are sold.


Pursuant to provisions of the New Jersey Licensed Alcoholic Beverage Server Fair Liability Act (N.J.S.A. 2A:22A-1,
et seq.) a person who sustained injuries or property damage as a result of the negligent service of alcoholic beverages by a licensed alcoholic beverage server may recover damages from that licensed alcoholic beverage server under certain circumstances. The law exists to hold establishments that are licensed to serve alcoholic beverages responsible for injuries that result form their negligent service of those beverages to the public.


That said, holding these establishments liable under the act can be difficult as recovery pursuant to the Act is limited to only two unique circumstances:


  1. Where the server of the alcoholic beverage negligently serves a visibly intoxicated person; or,
  2. Where the server of the alcoholic beverage negligently serves a minor and the server knew, or reasonably should have known, that the person served was a minor.


In addition, the party injured as a result of either of these circumstances may only recover if it can further be shown that: 1) their injury was proximately caused by the negligent service of the alcoholic beverages, and 2) that the injury or damage sustained was a foreseeable consequence of the negligent service of the alcoholic beverages.


Additionally, pursuant to the Licensed Alcoholic Beverage Server Fair Liability Act, recovery against the server of the alcoholic beverages is limited to recovery under the Act, as it is the exclusive civil remedy in dram shop cases involving a licensed server of alcoholic beverages. This means that in addition to suing the negligent bar under the Act, you could not then sue them under additional causes of action, such as negligent supervision, for example. Importantly, the “exclusive civil remedy” language of the act should not be confused to mean that recovery as against the negligent bar is the only potential recovery available to the injured party, because of course, they are free to pursue an action against the drunk driver as well.


What about Social Hosts?


Under the New Jersey Social Host Liability Act (N.J.S.A. 2A:15-5.5 to -5.8) social hosts in New Jersey have a similar duty of care to bartenders. As per the Act, a social host is “a person who, by express or implied invitation, invites another person onto an unlicensed premises for purposes of hospitality and who is not the holder of a liquor license for the premises and is not required to hold a liquor license for the premises under Title 33 of the Revised Statutes, and who legally provides alcoholic beverages to another person who has attainted the legal age to purchase and consume alcoholic beverages.”


In other words, the Act governs adults over the age of 21 who provide alcohol to another adult over the age of 21 at some place other than an establishment licensed to serve alcohol, such as at the person’s home. The Act, therefore, provides that if an adult over 21 hosts a party, for example, and serves alcoholic beverages to their guests who are also over 21 years old, the host can be liable if those guests become intoxicated and cause injury to a third-party. 


Interestingly, unlike licensed establishments, social hosts can also be liable for the self-service of alcohol left out for guests to partake of as they please, and even for alcoholic beverages that guests bring themselves. Holding social hosts liable in these situations highlights the intent behind the Act, that is to place an affirmative duty upon social hosts to maintain control over their intoxicated guests so as to safeguard the public, for example, by letting your drunk friend stay at the party until they sober up.

In all, dram shop liability, whether on the part of a licensed establishment or as a social host is something we should all be keeping in mind whenever the potential for drunk driving exists. If you or a loved one are injured as a result of an accident with a drunk driver, it is critically important to know what your rights are and to have knowledgeable and experienced legal representation. If you have been involved in such a motor vehicle accident, call the Lento Law Group today. Our team of experienced and dedicated attorneys will fight to ensure you receive the financial compensation you deserve!

More News & Resources

March 14, 2025
The expansion of nationwide licensure compacts impacts the ability of licensed professionals to gain and retain licenses. Get help.
December 5, 2024
By Terrell A. Ratliff, Esquire • 3 rd December, 2024
December 5, 2024
The Lento Law Group defends people accused of or charged with child abuse in Pennsylvania.
November 28, 2024
A 30-year-old woman in Oklahoma received a victim protection order (VPO) against her father after he beat her.
November 28, 2024
Bam Margera heads to rehab after a DUI arrest in Pennsylvania. Learn about DUI defense in Pennsylvania.
November 15, 2024
The House of Representatives has advanced an anti-hazing bill for Senate consideration that would increase hazing prevention.
By By Joseph Cannizzo, Esquire • 1 August, 2024 August 16, 2024
Surely no one would doubt that children are curious creatures, and as such, they often end up in places they don’t belong if they are not well looked after. The curiosity of a child’s mind knows no bounds, and while, as parents, we have come to expect simple “boo-boos” like a scrapped knee for example, sometimes curiosity can lead children into far more precarious situations. Obviously then, there are many situations where, from the worldview of an adult, while we see dangers that should best be avoided, a child may only see adventure – a new mystery waiting to be explored. While, of course, it is important that parents foster their children’s inquisitive minds, a parent’s first priority should surely always be to protect their children from serious bodily injury, or worse. Now that Summer is just around the corner, protecting our children is particularly important as swimming pools will start to be opened up and trampolines will be going back out in the yard. Fortunately, the law recognizes the tendency of children to view all the world as a playground, and imposes a special duty on owners of such things as swimming pools and trampolines to protect children from the hazard these things can represent. Like many states, New Jersey has adopted this principle of tort law, called the attractive nuisance doctrine. Put simply, an attractive nuisance is any man-made construct present upon land, which may lure children, and which can cause them bodily injury should they play on, in, or around it. The defining characteristic of an attractive nuisance is just that – that it is attractive to children and that the potential fun the attractive nuisance poses, entices a child like a moth to the flame. Swimming pools, playground equipment, and other artificial landscaping features can make your yard a magnet for every kid in the neighborhood, but the very things that might make your yard so enticing to a child may also be the very things that make it so potentially dangerous for them. As a result of this potential for harm, the law places a heightened duty on property owners who have items that will both attract children and present a unique potential for harm. The theory is that children are too young to appreciate the risk of harm these attractive nuisances pose, and therefore, because these items essentially induce a child into a hazardous area of your property, the property owner is expected to take special precautions to mitigate the risk of harm, for example, by putting a fence around a pool. Elements of Attractive Nuisance If the property owner knows, or reasonably should know, that children are likely to trespass upon his or her property; In response to an artificial condition present upon the land; Which the property owner knows, or reasonably should know poses an unreasonable risk of death or serious bodily injury; Such that a child, because of their youth, does not discover the condition or realize the risk involved; and Said property owner fails to take reasonable precautions to safeguard against the risk of injury. Common Attract Nuisances Water Features Studies suggest that an adult can drown from as little as six tablespoons of water. This number is even smaller for a child. Water features on property – including fountains, pools, and wells – can pose an enormous risk of drowning to children who may want to splash around inside, particularly if they cannot gauge how deep the water is, and especially if they have not yet learned to swim. A swimming pool is the most common example of an attractive nuisance, and as the summer weather soon comes upon us, pool owners – especially owners of inground pools – should be particularly mindful of the hazard posed by the attractive nuisance. As a pool owner, you could be liable for accidents even if children sneak into your pool without your consent. Whether the pool is in-ground, above ground, or even a kiddie pool, you can reduce your risk by surrounding your pool area with a fence, installing a locking gate (preferably one with an audible alarm), and covering the pool with a safety cover when not in use. New Jersey has passed legislation specifically outlined the heightened obligation of pool owners. Under New Jersey’s swimming pool safety act, called “William’s Law,” any pool must be fenced or walled in with a structure of at least 5 feet high and without any openings wide enough for a 4-inch object to pass through it. If a pool owner fails to properly enclose the water feature and a child is injured as a result, the child’s family may be able to sue under the attractive nuisance doctrine, as well as raise a negligence per se claim in connection with the pool owner’s violation of William’s Law. Trampolines & Playground Equipment Most home playground injuries involve swing sets, according to the Centers for Disease Control (CDC). To reduce the chance of accidents, therefore, the National Association of Home Inspectors recommends spacing swings at least 24 inches apart and at least 30 inches from the support frame. Swing sets – especially wooden ones – should be checked regularly for wear & tear, warping, or rot. Because most injuries from swings also involve falls, installing a shock-absorbing surface for your playground like sand, wood chips, or gravel, for example, can help mitigate the likelihood of injury. Trampolines can also pose a significant safety hazard to young children who may not know how to utilize one safely. If you are planning on purchasing a trampoline, look for a model that has a zippered entrance which can be locked. Additionally, consider installing a locked and alarmed fence around your yard or around the playground to make the feature inaccessible to uninvited users. Home Construction Projects Construction projects and the tools and equipment which may be present on a construction site can be kid magnets. Young children often get toy tool sets to play with, so seeing a real hammer or saw can be enticing. Rebuilding a deck, repaving a driveway, pouring concrete, building additions, and even repairing a roof can all present potentially dangerous conditions which a child may be drawn to. To some children, a ladder must be climbed or a hole must be jumped in. The law doesn’t expect homeowners to complete their construction projects overnight, but when stepping away, it is critical to turn off and put away power tools, remove heavy equipment if possible, and consider putting up hazard signs, safety cones, or even a barrier of caution tape to make the potential danger clearly evident. Our Tip: Be Alert to Hazards At the end of the day, even with due care it is impossible to prevent all eventualities, especially when children are involved, and unfortunately accidents do happen. At the same time, it is also important to be vigilant and to stay aware of hazardous or potentially hazardous conditions on our property which children may be drawn to. This is especially true if you live in a neighborhood with families who have children or near an area where children may be present, such as near a park or a school. Call The Lento Law Group If your child was the victim of an attractive nuisance or was otherwise injured on another person’s property, call the Lento Law Group today for a free phone consultation. Our caring, compassionate, and knowable staff will be happy to go over the facts of your potential case so that our experienced personal injury attorneys can see if you have a viable cause of action. There is absolutely no cost to you unless we secure a financial recovery on your behalf. Call today!
August 1, 2024
Alabama teacher and student rights bills highlight school tensions over student discipline. Let us help enforce your rights.
June 13, 2024
The mistakes of an assistant in a medical practice can threaten the medical professional’s license. Get skilled attorney defense.
June 13, 2024
By Larry Katz, Esquire • 12 June, 2024
More Posts